American Idol Season 10 “That Was It Haley”: Haley Reinhart Hits It With Elton John’s ‘Benny and the Jets”

Haley Reinhart, Wheeling
Haley Reinhart in top form Wednesday night before voting for American Idol Season 10 (2011) semifinals.

March 30, 2011 Update
All three judges give a big thumbs up for Haley’s cover “Bennie and the Jets” Wednesday night on American Idol.

Bennie and the Jets performed by Haley Reinhart Wednesday March 30, 2011.

“That was it, Haley!”
— Jennifer Lopez

“Best performance of the night.”
— Randy Jackson

“You Sing Sexy.”
— Steven Tyler

She’s got momentum. Could a cover song from Cher be in the wings?

March 23, 2011 Update